U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit
Commonwealth of Mass. v. National Institutes of Health
Panel
The judges who heard this appeal.
-
Judge
Julie Rikelman
Joseph R. Biden
-
Senior Judge
Kermit Victor Lipez
William J. Clinton
-
Senior Judge
Jeffrey R. Howard
George W. Bush
Case history
-
Jan. 5decided Decision issued in Commonwealth of Mass. v. National Institutes of Health
-
Nov. 5, 2025argued Oral argument in Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. National Institutes of Health