Benchlight The federal appellate judiciary

Active judges

JudgeStatusAppointed bySenate voteCommissioned
Jerome A. Holmes Chief Judge George W. Bush Republican 67/30 Aug. 9, 2006
Harris L. Hartz Active George W. Bush Republican 99/0 Dec. 10, 2001
Timothy M. Tymkovich Active George W. Bush Republican 58/41 April 1, 2003
Scott Milne Matheson Jr. Active Barack Obama Democratic — Dec. 27, 2010
Robert Edwin Bacharach Active Barack Obama Democratic 93/0 Feb. 28, 2013
Gregory Alan Phillips Active Barack Obama Democratic 88/0 July 9, 2013
Carolyn Baldwin McHugh Active Barack Obama Democratic 98/0 March 14, 2014
Nancy Louise Moritz Active Barack Obama Democratic 90/3 July 29, 2014
Allison Hartwell Eid Active Donald J. Trump Republican 56/41 Nov. 3, 2017
Joel McElroy Carson III Active Donald J. Trump Republican 77/21 May 17, 2018
Veronica Sophia Rossman Active Joseph R. Biden Democratic 50/42 Sept. 28, 2021
Richard Edward Neel Federico Active Joseph R. Biden Democratic 61/29 Dec. 13, 2023

Senior judges

Judges who have taken senior status and continue to hear cases.

JudgeStatusAppointed bySenate voteSenior status
Stephanie Kulp Seymour Senior Jimmy Carter Democratic — Oct. 16, 2005
John Carbone Porfilio Senior Ronald Reagan Republican — Oct. 15, 1999
Stephen Hale Anderson Senior Ronald Reagan Republican — Jan. 1, 2000
Bobby Ray Baldock Senior Ronald Reagan Republican — Jan. 26, 2001
Wade Brorby Senior Ronald Reagan Republican — May 25, 2001
David M. Ebel Senior Ronald Reagan Republican — Jan. 16, 2006
Paul Joseph Kelly Jr. Senior George H.W. Bush Republican — Dec. 31, 2017
Mary Beck Briscoe Senior William J. Clinton Democratic — March 15, 2021
Carlos F. Lucero Senior William J. Clinton Democratic — Feb. 1, 2021
Michael R. Murphy Senior William J. Clinton Democratic — Dec. 31, 2012
Terrence L. O'Brien Senior George W. Bush Republican 98/0 April 30, 2013

Appointment history

Sitting judges grouped by the party of the president who appointed them. This records who nominated each judge; Benchlight does not assign judges a political affiliation of their own.

Party of appointing presidentActiveSenior
Democratic 7 4
Republican 5 7

Computed by Benchlight Counted from Federal Judicial Center appointment records for judges currently in service on this court.

Recent cases

CaseNo.StatusDecided
Phillips v. Boilermaker-Blacksmith National Pension Trust 25-3160 Decided Sept. 29, 2026
Zeiner v. United States 25-3057 Argued — awaiting decision
United States v. Withrow 24-5040 Argued — awaiting decision
United States v. Taylor 25-5018 Argued — awaiting decision
United States v. Radick 25-7050 Argued — awaiting decision
United States v. Martin 25-7057 Argued — awaiting decision
United States v. Haight 25-5132 Argued — awaiting decision
Strine v. United States Center for Safe Sport 25-1407 Argued — awaiting decision
Second Green Mountain Townhouse Corp. v. Mesa Underwriters Specialty Insurance Company 25-1448 Argued — awaiting decision
Mostafa v. Blanche 25-1454 Argued — awaiting decision
Mendoza Gutierrez v. Baltasar 25-1460 Argued — awaiting decision
Flux Drive v. Sparks 25-1308 Argued — awaiting decision
EEOC v. A & A Appliance 25-1451 Argued — awaiting decision
Antwine v. Burton 25-6109 Argued — awaiting decision
American Food & Vending Corporation v. Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company 25-3187 Argued — awaiting decision