Benchlight The federal appellate judiciary

CERTIORARI -- SUMMARY DISPOSITION

  • Petition 25-1269

BURFORD GERMAN FUNDING, ET AL. V. FINANCIALRIGHT CLAIMS GMBH

The petition for a writ of certiorari is granted. The judgment is vacated, and the case is remanded to the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit for further consideration in light of Jules v. Andre Balazs Properties, 608 U. S. 200 (2026).

ORDERS IN PENDING CASES

  • Application 26A237

GOLDEN, CHIDDY V. TRANSUNION, LLC, ET AL.

The application for an injunction pending appeal addressed to Justice Thomas and referred to the Court is denied.

  • Application 26A265

EVANS, MARJORIE V. FED. HOME LOAN MORTGAGE, ET AL.

The application for stay addressed to Justice Alito and referred to the Court is denied.

  • Petition 26M27

RENTERIA, MARTIN V. UNITED STATES

The motion for leave to file a petition for a writ of certiorari with the supplemental appendix under seal is granted.

  • Petition 25-1391

BMG RIGHTS MANAGEMENT, ET AL. V. VETTER, CYRIL E., ET AL.

Because the Court lacks a quorum, 28 U. S. C. §1, and since the qualified Justices are of the opinion that the case cannot be heard and determined at the next Term of the Court, the judgment is affirmed under 28 U. S. C. §2109, which provides that under these circumstances "the court shall enter its order affirming the judgment of the court from which the case was brought for review with the same effect as upon affirmance by an equally divided court." Justice Sotomayor, Justice Gorsuch, Justice Barrett, and Justice Jackson took no part in the consideration or decision of this petition.

  • Petition 26-49

BIRD, ATT'Y GEN. OF IA V. IOWA MIGRANT MOVEMENT, ET AL.

The Solicitor General is invited to file a brief in this case expressing the views of the United States.

CERTIORARI GRANTED

  • Petition 26-12

ASS'N FOR ED. FAIRNESS V. MONTGOMERY CTY. BD. ED., ET AL.

The petition for a writ of certiorari is granted limited to the following question: Whether a plaintiff challenging a facially neutral admissions policy as racially discriminatory must establish that the targeted racial group suffered an aggregate disparate impact relative to its share of the applicant pool.

  • Petition 26-204

DEPT. OF JUSTICE, ET AL. V. SCOTT McNUTT, ET AL.

The petition for a writ of certiorari is granted.

CERTIORARI DENIED

  • Petition 25-1158

HADLEY, AMY V. SOUTH BEND, IN, ET AL.

  • Petition 25-1163

PENA, CARLOS V. LOS ANGELES, CA

  • Petition 25-1230

GOOGLE LLC V. VIRTAMOVE, CORP., ET AL.

  • Petition 25-1231

HASTINGS COLLEGE COMM., ET AL. V. CALIFORNIA, ET AL.

  • Petition 25-1314

GOMEZ, ERIC V. SACCOCCIO, DAVID

  • Petition 25-1335

bIN ‘ATASH, WALID V. UNITED STATES

  • Petition 25-1372

ASG SOLUTIONS CORP. V. UNITED STATES

  • Petition 25-7371

McMICHAEL, TRAVIS V. UNITED STATES

  • Petition 25-7478

HARRIS, MICHAEL V. UNITED STATES

  • Petition 25-7530

LANDRUM, LESTER V. UNITED STATES

  • Petition 26-5

WILCOX, GWYNNE A. V. TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF U.S., ET AL.

  • Petition 26-32

AARON, BREAYONNA, ET AL. V. NAT. R.R. PASSENGER CORP.

  • Petition 26-58

KILNAPP, JENNIFER V. GANNON, BAILEY

  • Petition 26-114

ALLEN, FREDERICK L., ET AL. V. STEIN, GOV. OF NC, ET AL.

  • Petition 26-164

A. A., ET AL. V. MAST, JOSHUA, ET AL.

  • Petition 26-191

COPELAND, BRUCE D. V. McCLINTOCK, EVA, ET AL.

  • Petition 26-209

MIDDLEBROOKS, LILLIE M. V. KASMAR, SCOTT, ET AL.

  • Petition 26-213

COOK, NYANZA V. WILLIS, KELVIN, ET AL.

  • Petition 26-214

FIEDLER, MURIEL, ET VIR V. U.S. BANK TRUST N.A.

  • Petition 26-217

DEAN, SHERIFF V. BOND, AUSTIN P.

  • Petition 26-225

CEMEX CONSTR. MATERIALS PAC. V. NLRB, ET AL.

  • Petition 26-226

MAST, JOSHUA, ET AL. V. DOE, JOHN, ET AL.

  • Petition 26-248

GOLDEN, LARRY V. UNITED STATES

  • Petition 26-258

BECKWITH, ANDREA, ET AL. V. FREY, ATT'Y GEN. OF ME

  • Petition 26-266

VICARIO, STEVEN V. OHIO

  • Petition 26-269

CARDIFF, JASON E. T. V. USDC CD CA, ET AL.

  • Petition 26-289

BRUNSWICK, GA V. HONEYWELL INT'L, INC., ET AL.

  • Petition 26-309

CANTU, ISRAEL V. COLLINS, SEC. OF VA

  • Petition 26-327

BARNETT-MORGAN, RENETE V. INVERNESS TECHNOLOGIES, INC.

  • Petition 26-361

NM TRAPPERS ASSN., ET AL. V. TORREZ, ATT'Y GEN. OF NM, ET AL.

  • Petition 26-373

JOHNSON, ANTOINE D. V. UNITED STATES

  • Petition 26-5318

SMITH FUNDERBURG, BRANDY V. HRC DEPT. OF SOCIAL SERVICES

  • Petition 26-5320

STEPHENS, LINH T. V. OK DEPT. HUMAN SERVICES, ET AL.

  • Petition 26-5321

GREENE, DAVID V. IGC MS. PULLIAM, ET AL.

  • Petition 26-5328

JU, MAO V. BRIGHT, FOREST M.

  • Petition 26-5330

E. R. V. NJ DIV. OF CHILD PROTECTION

  • Petition 26-5338

GIGENA, GABRIEL O. V. NIELSON, HOWARD C., ET AL.

  • Petition 26-5339

PERKINS, CASSANDRA V. USDC ND GA, ET AL.

  • Petition 26-5341

CORDERO, MISAEL V. KELLEY, GREGORY, ET AL.

  • Petition 26-5345

DAVIS, JASPER V. GUERRERO, DIR., TX DCJ

  • Petition 26-5350

SOUARE, ELHADJ A. M. V. AKRON METRO. HOUS. AUTH., ET AL.

  • Petition 26-5352

JOHNSON, HARRIUS V. MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FL

  • Petition 26-5358

TATAS, MEHMET E. V. ALI BABA'S TERRACE INC., ET AL.

  • Petition 26-5359

CLARK, WILLIAM R. V. WY DOC, ET AL.

  • Petition 26-5365

STONE, EMMA V. EXTRA SPACE MANAGEMENT, ET AL.

  • Petition 26-5388

RODRIGUEZ, HIRAN V. META PLATFORMS, INC., ET AL.

  • Petition 26-5390

THORTON, KENNETH E. V. BEAVER CTY, PA, ET AL.

  • Petition 26-5396

LOWERY, MARGARET J. V. OK, EX REL. OK BAR ASSN.

  • Petition 26-5398

PERRY, DeTRON L. V. BOTTLINGER, JASON B., ET AL.

  • Petition 26-5402

CLARK, NICOLAS A. V. PERKINS, JEFFEREY, ET AL.

  • Petition 26-5410

MARTIN, ELIZABETH J. V. DEPT. OF VA

  • Petition 26-5436

WILLIAMS, DEBBIE V. HOLT, RODNEY, ET AL.

  • Petition 26-5443

) TZUNUX-ZACARIAS, MARIO V. KENTUCKY

)

  • Petition 26-5521

) TZUNUX-ZACARIAS, ISABEL V. KENTUCKY

  • Petition 26-5459

WISEMAN, RICHARD V. CALIFORNIA

  • Petition 26-5465

STUKEL, MITCHELL V. FLORIDA

  • Petition 26-5477

KIRK, KEVIN V. NIPD-NJ

  • Petition 26-5525

McGEE, LOLA B. V. STEINER, POSTMASTER GEN., ET AL.

  • Petition 26-5533

BRAUN, SUSAN V. SAGER, TRACEY, ET AL.

  • Petition 26-5535

MARTIN, DONTAY D. V. ENGLISH, WARDEN

  • Petition 26-5560

SADEEK, EHAB V. UNITED STATES

  • Petition 26-5599

ROMERO, FRANK V. FHUERE, SUPT., OR

  • Petition 26-5603

THOMAS, BRYAN O. V. UNITED STATES

  • Petition 26-5605

FOWLER, MARC S. V. UNITED STATES

  • Petition 26-5609

LARKINS, RODERICK V. UNITED STATES

  • Petition 26-5619

WALKER, THOMAS G. V. PIERCE, WARDEN, ET AL.

  • Petition 26-5623

CARSON, ADAM V. UNITED STATES

  • Petition 26-5649

SULLIVAN, PATRICK J. V. MINNESOTA

  • Petition 25-1115

UTAH V. MULLINS, MORRIS T.

The motion of respondent for leave to proceed in forma pauperis is granted. The petition for a writ of certiorari is denied.

  • Petition 26-13

MOHAMMAD, KHALID S., ET AL. V. UNITED STATES

The petition for a writ of certiorari is denied. Justice Kavanaugh took no part in the consideration or decision of this petition.

  • Petition 26-34

HANAWAY, ATT'Y GEN. MO., ET AL. V. SANDERSON, THOMAS

The petition for a writ of certiorari is denied. Justice Alito would grant the petition for a writ of certiorari.

  • Petition 25-7647

BORNEMANN, GINA P. V. BORNEMANN, PAUL H.

The motion of respondent for leave to file a brief in opposition under seal with redacted copies for the public record is granted. The petition for a writ of certiorari is denied.

  • Petition 26-5355

MANAOLE, DE MONT K. V. OFFICE OF HI AFFAIRS, ET AL.

The petition for a writ of certiorari before judgment is denied.

  • Petition 26-5615

EARLS, FAIRLY W. V. GIROUX, WARDEN

The petition for a writ of certiorari is denied. Justice Barrett took no part in the consideration or decision of this petition.

Cite as: 610 U. S. ____ (2026) 1

Statement of SOTOMAYOR, J. SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

RYAN O’DONNELL, ET AL. v. CITY OF CHICAGO,

ILLINOIS, ET AL.

ON PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED

STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT

No. 25–1098. Decided October 19, 2026

The petition for a writ of certiorari is denied.

Statement of JUSTICE SOTOMAYOR, with whom JUSTICE GORSUCH joins, respecting the denial of certiorari.

In Chicago, a driver who fails to pay as few as two park- ing tickets risks forfeiting his vehicle to the city. The city then can do as it pleases with the vehicle, with no obligation to pay compensation, offset the unpaid ticket debt, or return any surplus to the owner if the vehicle is sold for a profit. See Chicago, Ill., Municipal Code §§9–100–120(b), (f ) (2026). The Seventh Circuit upheld that scheme as con- sistent with the Fifth Amendment’s Takings Clause, rea- soning that it is “an exercise of the City’s police power to enforce its traffic code.” 163 F. 4th 411, 414 (2025). I have serious concerns about that conclusion, which implicates a Circuit split over whether, and under what circumstances, exercises of the State’s police power are immune to takings claims. Because that split would continue to benefit from further percolation, however, and because this case is not the best vehicle to resolve the split, I concur in the Court’s denial of certiorari.

Chicago’s vehicle-forfeiture scheme is vast and lucrative, helping the city generate, according to one estimate, $264 million in traffic-ticket revenue (or 7 percent of the city’s operating budget) in 2016. See M. Sanchez & S. Kambham- pati, How Chicago Ticket Debt Sends Black Motorists Into Bankruptcy, ProPublica (Feb. 27, 2018), https://fea- tures.propublica.org/driven-into-debt/chicago-ticket-debt- 2 O’DONNELL v. CITY OF CHICAGO

Statement of SOTOMAYOR, J. bankruptcy/ (archived at https:// perma.cc/K8MU-KVTW). Petitioners Ryan O’Donnell and Michael Goree are two of the many Chicago motorists sub- ject to that scheme. According to the complaint filed in this case, O’Donnell received two tickets for an expired meter and one ticket for time-restricted parking, totaling approx- imately $524. Goree did not have any tickets himself; ra- ther, a co-signer on his vehicle had approximately $560 of outstanding ticket debt from a different vehicle. After those tickets went unpaid, the city towed and impounded peti- tioners’ vehicles, adding additional boot, tow, and storage fees. It then sold O’Donnell’s vehicle for its scrap value of $273 and relinquished Goree’s vehicle to the lienholder. Neither petitioner received any compensation for the loss of their cars.

Petitioners sued the city, alleging that its scheme facially violates the Takings Clause, which bars taking “private property” for “public use, without just compensation.” They asserted that §9–100–120 empowers the city to take vehi- cles “without providing any compensation to the owner or even a hearing to determine fair compensation.” Complaint in No. 1:23–cv–01192 (ND Ill.), ECF Doc. 1, ¶73. The Dis- trict Court dismissed the suit, see App. to Pet. for Cert. 16– 18; and the Seventh Circuit affirmed, see 163 F. 4th, at 414–415. As relevant here, the Seventh Circuit rejected pe- titioners’ argument that Chicago’s vehicle-forfeiture scheme is like the tax-forfeiture statute this Court invali- dated in Tyler v. Hennepin County, 598 U. S. 631 (2023), for failure to return any surplus to the homeowner after a tax sale. The better analogy, the Seventh Circuit reasoned, was to Bennis v. Michigan, 516 U. S. 442 (1996), where this Court held that the government may seize property used in the violation of the law without providing any compensa- tion to the owner. See 163 F. 4th, at 414–415 (citing Bennis, 516 U. S., at 453); see also id., at 452 (forfeitures that

Cite as: 610 U. S. ____ (2026) 3

Statement of SOTOMAYOR, J. comport with due process do not trigger the duty of just compensation).

Unlike the laws discussed in Bennis, however, Chicago does not impound only those vehicles involved in violations of its municipal traffic code. Rather, the city may impound any vehicle of a delinquent resident so long as ticket debts remain unpaid, regardless of whether the vehicle was in- volved in an infraction. §9–100–120(b). Indeed, that is pre- cisely what happened to Goree, who lost his car because a co-owner incurred ticket debt on a different vehicle. After the vehicle is impounded, moreover, forfeiture is a conse- quence only of the failure to pay, not the antecedent legal infraction. §9–100–120(f ). Those features strongly suggest that “the purpose of vehicle impoundments” under Chi- cago’s scheme “is to collect a debt, not enforce public safety laws.” Pet. for Cert. 10. If so, then Tyler would seem to control, and the city’s failure to compensate owners for the loss of their vehicles would likely violate the Takings Clause. The city’s practice of surrendering cars to lienhold- ers or selling them for their scrap value, rather than at a fair auction, only amplifies the potential constitutional in- firmity. Cf. Pung v. Isabella County, 609 U. S. 30, 33 (2026) (just compensation is measured based on “fairly conducted” tax sale).

Because of its mistaken reliance on Bennis, the Seventh Circuit considered Chicago’s vehicle-forfeiture scheme “a ‘classic example’ ” of the State’s “police power.” 163 F. 4th, at 414 (quoting Hadley v. South Bend, 154 F. 4th 549, 556 (CA7 2025)). As I have previously written, the lower courts are divided over “the extent to which the Takings Clause applies to exercises of the police power.” Baker v. City of McKinney, 604 U. S. 1035, 1038 (2024) (statement of SOTOMAYOR, J., respecting denial of certiorari). Here, the Seventh Circuit embraced the expansive notion that “exer- cise[s] of the City’s police power to enforce its traffic code” are immune to takings claims. 163 F. 4th, at 414. Some 4 O’DONNELL v. CITY OF CHICAGO

Statement of SOTOMAYOR, J. courts have likewise appeared to adopt a categorical rule that the Takings Clause does not apply when the govern- ment acts under any of its police powers. See, e.g., Amer- iSource Corp. v. United States, 525 F. 3d 1149, 1153 (CA Fed. 2008); Lech v. Jackson, 791 Fed. Appx. 711, 717 (CA10 2019). Others have held, more narrowly, that the just-com- pensation requirement is subject to a public-safety or ne- cessity exception, see, e.g., Baker v. McKinney, 84 F. 4th 378, 388 (CA5 2023); Pena v. Los Angeles, 158 F. 4th 1033, 1035 (CA9 2025), or that no property is taken when it is damaged incident to a lawful search or arrest, see, e.g., Slaybaugh v. Rutherford County, 114 F. 4th 593, 598 (CA6 2024); Hadley, 154 F. 4th, at 554; Pena, 158 F. 4th, at 1050 (Friedland, J., concurring in judgment). It is still an “open question” whether these or any other approaches are con- sistent with this Court’s precedents. Baker, 604 U. S., at 1038. Few of these decisions likewise explain the source of any such police-power exception to the Takings Clause— whether the common law, the Constitution, or elsewhere.

Such questions thus continue to “benefit from further per- colation” in the lower courts before this Court chooses to in- tervene. Id., at 1039. Petitioners, moreover, have lodged a facial challenge to Chicago’s ordinance, which might re- quire this Court to invalidate even those features of the law that have nothing to do with vehicle forfeiture. See, e.g., §9–100–120(a) (providing for immobilization of vehicles). I therefore concur in the Court’s denial of certiorari. I none- theless write to emphasize that courts should carefully and narrowly define the circumstances in which the State’s ex- ercise of its police powers are held exempt from the just- compensation requirement, as well as explain the source of any such exemption. Where, as here, a person alleges a “classic taking in which the government directly appropri- ates private property for its own use” or to pay an outstand- ing debt, like a tax lien, Tyler, 598 U. S., at 639 (internal quotation marks omitted), the talismanic invocation of the

Cite as: 610 U. S. ____ (2026) 5

Statement of SOTOMAYOR, J. State’s “law enforcement authority,” 163 F. 4th, at 414, may be insufficient to avoid the requirement of just compensa- tion. I again encourage courts considering this issue to take care that due deference to state police powers does not eclipse constitutional rights.

The petitions for writs of certiorari are denied.

Noted dissents HANAWAY, ATT'Y GEN. MO., ET AL. V. SANDERSON, THOMASEARLS, FAIRLY W. V. GIROUX, WARDEN