Benchlight The federal appellate judiciary

Panel

The judges who heard this appeal.

Case history

  • July 23
    decided Decision issued in Sandra Gail Carrin v. Shauna Marie Smiledge
  • June 23
    argued Oral argument in Sandra Gail Carrin v. Shauna Marie Smiledge, Joseph Jimenez

Opinions and writings

Opinion of the Court By Elizabeth Lee Branch July 23, 2026

Open in Benchlight Court PDF

Concurrence By Robin Stacie Rosenbaum July 23, 2026

Open in Benchlight Court PDF