Benchlight The federal appellate judiciary

Active judges

JudgeStatusAppointed bySenate voteCommissioned
Raymond Joseph Lohier Jr. Chief Judge Barack Obama Democratic 92/0 Dec. 20, 2010
Richard Joseph Sullivan Active Donald J. Trump Republican 79/16 Oct. 17, 2018
Joseph Frank Bianco Active Donald J. Trump Republican 54/42 May 13, 2019
Michael Hun Park Active Donald J. Trump Republican 52/41 May 13, 2019
Steven James Menashi Active Donald J. Trump Republican 51/41 Nov. 14, 2019
William Joseph Nardini Active Donald J. Trump Republican 86/2 Nov. 14, 2019
Eunice Cheryl Lee Active Joseph R. Biden Democratic 50/47 Aug. 16, 2021
Beth Robinson Active Joseph R. Biden Democratic 51/45 Nov. 5, 2021
Myrna Pérez Active Joseph R. Biden Democratic 48/43 Nov. 12, 2021
Alison Julie Nathan Active Joseph R. Biden Democratic 49/47 March 30, 2022
Sarah Ann Leilani Merriam Active Joseph R. Biden Democratic 53/44 Sept. 23, 2022
Maria Araujo Kahn Active Joseph R. Biden Democratic 51/42 March 10, 2023
Matthew Alexander Schwartz Active Donald J. Trump Republican 50/45 July 24, 2026

Senior judges

Judges who have taken senior status and continue to hear cases.

JudgeStatusAppointed bySenate voteSenior status
Jon Ormond Newman Senior Jimmy Carter Democratic — July 1, 1997
Amalya Lyle Kearse Senior Jimmy Carter Democratic — June 11, 2002
John Mercer Walker Jr. Senior George H.W. Bush Republican — Sept. 30, 2006
Dennis G. Jacobs Senior George H.W. Bush Republican — May 31, 2019
Pierre Nelson Leval Senior William J. Clinton Democratic — Aug. 16, 2002
Guido Calabresi Senior William J. Clinton Democratic — July 21, 2009
José Alberto Cabranes Senior William J. Clinton Democratic — March 9, 2023
Robert David Sack Senior William J. Clinton Democratic — Aug. 6, 2009
Barrington Daniels Parker Jr. Senior George W. Bush Republican 100/0 Oct. 10, 2009
Reena Raggi Senior George W. Bush Republican 85/0 Aug. 31, 2018
Richard C. Wesley Senior George W. Bush Republican 96/0 Aug. 1, 2016
Debra Ann Livingston Senior George W. Bush Republican 91/0 July 1, 2026
Gerard E. Lynch Senior Barack Obama Democratic 94/3 Sept. 5, 2016
Denny Chin Senior Barack Obama Democratic 98/0 June 1, 2021
Susan Laura Carney Senior Barack Obama Democratic 71/28 Sept. 27, 2022

Appointment history

Sitting judges grouped by the party of the president who appointed them. This records who nominated each judge; Benchlight does not assign judges a political affiliation of their own.

Party of appointing presidentActiveSenior
Democratic 7 9
Republican 6 6

Computed by Benchlight Counted from Federal Judicial Center appointment records for judges currently in service on this court.

Awaiting decision

Argued, with no decision recorded here.

CaseNo.Argued
Sava v. Blanche 24-1192 Oct. 26, 2026
A.H. v. New York City Department of Education 25-2727 Oct. 26, 2026
United States v. Jabar (Bowers) 25-1118, 25-1164 Oct. 26, 2026
United States v. Fox 24-2529 Oct. 26, 2026
Moy v. Napoli Shkolnik, PLLC 25-2528 Oct. 26, 2026
Jenkins v. Miller 25-1993 Oct. 23, 2026
McCartney v. City of New York 25-2535 Oct. 23, 2026
Northwell Health, Inc. v. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Massachusetts, Inc. 25-3214 Oct. 23, 2026
National Credit Union Administration Board v. Kaufman 25-1665 Oct. 23, 2026
Margules v. Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company 25-2241 Oct. 23, 2026

Benchlight records a decision when a source publishes one. Most appeals are resolved by unpublished disposition, which its sources do not carry, so a case may appear here after the court has ruled.

Recent cases

CaseNo.StatusDecided
United States v. Jabar (Bowers) 25-1118, 25-1164 Argued — awaiting decision
United States v. Fox 24-2529 Argued — awaiting decision
Sava v. Blanche 24-1192 Argued — awaiting decision
Moy v. Napoli Shkolnik, PLLC 25-2528 Argued — awaiting decision
A.H. v. New York City Department of Education 25-2727 Argued — awaiting decision
United States v. Kirik 25-796 Argued — awaiting decision
Northwell Health, Inc. v. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Massachusetts, Inc. 25-3214 Argued — awaiting decision
National Credit Union Administration Board v. Kaufman 25-1665 Argued — awaiting decision
McCartney v. City of New York 25-2535 Argued — awaiting decision
Margules v. Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company 25-2241 Argued — awaiting decision
Jenkins v. Miller 25-1993 Argued — awaiting decision
Government Employees Insurance Company v. Clarke 24-1611 Argued — awaiting decision
Clark v. St. Lawrence County 25-1989 Argued — awaiting decision
Black Love Resists in the Rust v. City of Buffalo 25-2216 Argued — awaiting decision
Strom v. Cardona 25-2066, 25-2196 Argued — awaiting decision