Benchlight The federal appellate judiciary

Appointment

Court
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit
Title
Judge
Appointed by
George H.W. BushRepublican
Seat
CA20902
Nominated
Sept. 21, 1989
Committee hearing
Nov. 7, 1989
Committee action
Reported (favorably)Nov. 16, 1989
Senate vote
Voice
Confirmed
Nov. 22, 1989
Commissioned
Nov. 27, 1989
ABA rating
Well Qualified
Chief Judge from
Jan. 1, 2000until Jan. 1, 2006
Senior status
Sept. 30, 2006

Source Federal Judicial Center.

Judicial service history

Every federal judicial office held, in order of appointment.

CourtTitleCommissionedEndedAppointed by
U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge July 22, 1985 Dec. 19, 1989 Appointment to Another Judicial Position Ronald Reagan
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit Judge Nov. 27, 1989 In service George H.W. Bush

Recent judicial activity

Opinions authored and panels sat on, most recent first.

Cases

Appellate cases on which this judge sat, drawn from panel information published with each decision.

CaseNo.StatusDate
Roa v. Hermes Law 24-3223 Decided Sept. 30, 2026
Siren Retail Corp. v. NLRB 24-3168 Decided Sept. 2, 2026
United States v. DeFelice 25-920 Decided Sept. 2, 2026
Wong v. Blanche 22-6185 Decided Aug. 19, 2026
Stinn v. United States 25-293 Decided Aug. 17, 2026
United States v. McCrone 22-3178 Decided July 21, 2026
The New York and Presbyterian Hospital v. New York State Nurses Association 25-113 Decided July 7, 2026
Levin, Vodka Properties LLC v. City of Buffalo 25-762 Decided June 18, 2026
Knapp v. Barclays 25-1631 Decided March 24, 2026
Peña Garcia v. Department of Labor 23-8066 Decided March 5, 2026
Baroni v. Port Authority of New York and New Jersey 23-916 Decided Dec. 2, 2025
Alessi Equip., Inc. v. Am. Piledriving Equip., Inc. 22-2317 Decided Nov. 21, 2025
Moore v. Rubin 24-2018 Decided Nov. 21, 2025
Nat'l Ass'n for Gun Rights v. Lamont; Grant v. Rovella 23-1162-cv; 23-1344-cv Decided Aug. 22, 2025
Carruthers v. Colton 22-3234 Decided Aug. 20, 2025
Collins v. Ne. Grocery, LLC 24-2339 Decided Aug. 18, 2025
United States v. Prawl 23-6313 Decided Aug. 18, 2025
In Re: Enforcement of Philippine Forfeiture Judgment 24-185(L) Decided Aug. 18, 2025
Liberty Insurance Corp. v. Hudson Excess Insurance Co. 23-1208 Decided Aug. 13, 2025
Thermal Surgical, LLC v. Brown 24-127 Decided Aug. 8, 2025

Judicial writings

Opinions, concurrences and dissents attributed to this judge by the source record.

TypeCaseCourtFiled
Opinion Lugo v. the City of Troy, New York Second Circuit Aug. 27, 2024
Opinion City of New York v. Henriquez Second Circuit April 16, 2024
Opinion Daileader v. Certain Underwriters at Lloyds London Syndicate 1861 Second Circuit March 18, 2024
Opinion United States v. Jimenez Second Circuit March 15, 2024
Opinion United States v. Hunt Second Circuit Sept. 20, 2023
Opinion FAT Brands Inc. v. Ramjeet Second Circuit July 25, 2023
Opinion Tyler v. Kingston Second Circuit July 18, 2023
Opinion United States v. Davis Second Circuit July 18, 2023
Opinion United States v. Aybar-Peguero Second Circuit July 6, 2023
Opinion Spetner v. PIB Second Circuit June 16, 2023
Opinion Seneca Nation v. Hochul Second Circuit Jan. 26, 2023
Opinion United States v. McIntosh Second Circuit Jan. 25, 2023
Opinion United States v. Rakhmatov Second Circuit Nov. 17, 2022
Opinion Lawyers' Committee v. Garland Second Circuit Aug. 5, 2022
Opinion Stone v. United States Second Circuit June 21, 2022
Opinion United States v. Capelli Second Circuit June 21, 2022
Opinion United States v. McIntosh Second Circuit Jan. 31, 2022
Opinion Tantaros v. Fox News Network, LLC Second Circuit Aug. 27, 2021
Opinion Horn Jackson v. Stephenson Second Circuit Aug. 26, 2021
Opinion United States v. Perez Second Circuit July 29, 2021