Nathan Roberts v. Progressive Preferred Ins. Co.

Panel

The judges who heard this appeal.

Senior Judge Danny Julian Boggs Ronald Reagan
Senior Judge David William McKeague George W. Bush
Judge Andre Bernard Mathis Joseph R. Biden

Case history

May 19

decided Decision issued in Nathan Roberts v. Progressive Preferred Ins. Co.
July 24, 2025

argued Oral argument in Nathan Roberts v. Progressive Preferred Ins Co

Opinions and writings

Opinion of the Court By Amul Roger Thapar May 19, 2026

Open in Benchlight Court PDF

Opinion of the Court By Andre Bernard Mathis Feb. 24, 2026

Open in Benchlight Court PDF

Dissent By Danny Julian Boggs Feb. 24, 2026

Open in Benchlight Court PDF

Dissent By Amul Roger Thapar May 19, 2026

Open in Benchlight Court PDF

Dissent By Whitney Downs Hermandorfer May 19, 2026

Open in Benchlight Court PDF

Writing By Amul Roger Thapar May 19, 2026

Open in Benchlight Court PDF

Case record

Court: Sixth Circuit
Docket number: 24-3454
Status: Decided
Filed: May 29, 2024
Argued: July 24, 2025
Decided: May 19, 2026
Terminated: Feb. 24, 2026
Last filing: July 24, 2026
Publication: Published
Nature of suit: 3440 Civil Rights: Other
Case type: Civil, Private, Civil Rights

Origin

Court below: United States District Court for the Northern District of Ohio at Cleveland
Docket below: 1:23-cv-01597

Oral argument

Argued: July 24, 2025
Duration: 42 minutes

Source Argument audio streams from the court that recorded it. Benchlight links to the recording and does not host it; the listing comes from CourtListener.