Luther Poynter v. Aaron Shirley

The judges who heard this appeal.

• Judge Karen Nelson Moore William J. Clinton
• Chief Judge Jeffrey S. Sutton George W. Bush
• Judge Eric L. Clay William J. Clinton
• Senior Judge Helene N. White George W. Bush
• Judge Richard Allen Griffin George W. Bush
• Judge Raymond M. Kethledge George W. Bush
• Judge Amul Roger Thapar Donald J. Trump
• Judge John Kenneth Bush Donald J. Trump
• Judge Joan Louise Larsen Donald J. Trump
• Judge John Baylor Nalbandian Donald J. Trump
• Judge Chad Andrew Readler Donald J. Trump
• Judge Eric Earl Murphy Donald J. Trump
• Judge Stephanie Dawkins Davis Joseph R. Biden
• Judge Andre Bernard Mathis Joseph R. Biden
• Judge Rachel Sarah Bloomekatz Joseph R. Biden
• Judge Kevin Gafford Ritz Joseph R. Biden
• Judge Whitney Downs Hermandorfer Donald J. Trump

• Sept. 8
  decided Decision issued in Luther Poynter v. Aaron Shirley
• Oct. 21, 2025
  argued Oral argument in Luther Poynter v. Aaron Bennett