Donna Dutton v. Jimmy Shaffer · Benchlight

Skip to content

Panel

The judges who heard this appeal.

Senior Judge Julia Smith Gibbons George W. Bush
Senior Judge Helene N. White George W. Bush
Judge Eric Earl Murphy Donald J. Trump

Case history

April 1

decided Decision issued in Donna Dutton v. Jimmy Shaffer
March 5

argued Oral argument in Donna Dutton v. Jimmy Shaffer

Opinions and writings

Opinion By Julia Smith Gibbons April 1, 2026

Open in Benchlight Court PDF