Virginia Duncan v. Rob Bonta

The judges who heard this appeal.

• Senior Judge Sidney Runyan Thomas William J. Clinton
• Senior Judge Susan Graber William J. Clinton
• Senior Judge Richard A. Paez William J. Clinton
• Senior Judge Marsha Siegel Berzon William J. Clinton
• Judge Sandra Segal Ikuta George W. Bush
• Chief Judge Mary Helen Murguia Barack Obama
• Judge Paul Jeffrey Watford Barack Obama
• Senior Judge Andrew David Hurwitz Barack Obama
• Judge Ryan Douglas Nelson Donald J. Trump
• Judge Patrick Joseph Bumatay Donald J. Trump
• Judge Lawrence James Christopher VanDyke Donald J. Trump

• Nov. 30, 2021
  decided Decision issued in Virginia Duncan v. Rob Bonta